Friday, December 02, 2005

Bewitched

OK, so I went to the Christian book store (the white, Anglo-Saxon, protestant, evangelical, upper-middle class, republican, family values propaganda store) in the area, and I was hit immediately by the overwhelming amount of Narnia crap that absolutely filled the place. Disney has marketed this film to Christians in a way that only the Disney advertising juggernaut can, and I find it all hard to take in. It may be that I just barely missed being attacked by the live lion they had prowling around the store as a way of drawing attention to the Narnia display (thank God he found that cute little blond-haired 5 year old boy instead of me) (I think the lion was attracted to the smell of stolen "Testamints" candy on the kid's breath). It may be that I love the books and even read them to my unborn daughter while she was in the womb, and I am very afraid that Disney will destroy my favorite books. I think I have figured out the three main reasons for my disturbed feelings:

1) Disney and Evangelicals Make Strange Bedfellows

Evangelical Christianity has a long, happy history of protesting everything Disney. The very existence of Disney has been a thorn in the side of Evangelicals for years. Christians love to portray Disney as the Magic Kingdom of Satan (mostly because of Disney's acceptance of "The Gays") Disney, for its part, is quintessential US consummerist culture. Disney is the Evil Galactic Empire. It is all about buying and consumption. Looking back at the astronomical success of Mel Gibson's The Passion, Disney wants to grab some of those Christian bucks. Disney and Evangelicals working together is as disturbing to me as the union of Flava Flav and Brigitte Nielsen.

2) White American Evangelicals Will Co-opt the World, If They Can

The Passion, Left Behind, multi-colored leather bibles, X-treme faith stuff, Christian hip-hop, and other such stuff are all examples of boomer generation Christianity trying to look cool to my generation and younger. I am an "Xer", and it started with marketing youth groups to my generation and grew from there. We had "X-treme Ski Trips", "X-treme Pizza Blasts", and X-treme Contemplative Retreats" pitched at us ad nauseum. The difficulty with this is twofold. First, it is a self-deception on the part of Christians. We have fooled ourselves into believing we are the controllers in this consummerist marketing Christian explosion. Sorry. Mega-conglomerates like Disney laugh at these naive simpletons who were protesting them yesterday and are now PAYING CHURCH FUNDS TO MARKET FOR DISNEY!!! Disney no longer has to even spend for its own advertising. I have no problem with Disney. In fact, I already have my tickets to see the movie with my kids. However, you will never see a shred of Narnia advertising in my church. I am not saying I am above anyone else. I am just sick of seeing the Church that I love act like a whore, spreading her legs for whatever company or product comes with a smile and a nice ad pitch. John Cusak, an actor who has become a pseudo-voice for my generation, summed up our feelings best in "Say Anything" as Lloyd:

"A career? I've thought about this quite a bit sir and I would have to say
considering what's waiting out there for me, I don't want to sell anything, buy
anything or process anything as a career. I don't want to sell anything bought or
processed or buy anything sold or processed or repair anything sold, bought or
processed as a career. I don't want to do that. My father's in the army. He wants
me to join, but I can't work for that corporation, so what I've been doing
lately is kick-boxing, which is a new sport...As far as career longevity, I don't
really know. I cant figure it all out tonight, sir, so I'm just gonna hang with
your daughter."

3) Pretty Picky With Our Witches, Aren't We?

I love C.S. Lewis' Narnia books, as I said earlier, but please. Why is this British witch acceptable and Harry Potter is the devil? I love the Harry Potter books as well. There are a number of lessons in those books about growing up, facing fears, and handling the worst of life. Yet, Christians have avidly protested the books and the movies. They have been very self-righteous as they have driven to bookstores and theaters in their GM SUVs (burning a ton of gas, while GM has been liked to Apartheid in South Africa) to march in their Nikes (made in Indonesian sweat shops) while drinking Coca-Cola (linked to murders of Columbian peasants) bought from Wal-mart (guilty of almost completely destroying the US small market economy and keeping minimum wage at an unjust level), while they burn books in front of the children who love them (causing these kids to have a horrible first experience of Christianity). The Lewis books are full of magic and fantasy, but they are acceptable, because they have been marketed to Christians. The fact is, Lewis did not write them for Christians or even as an evangelistic tool. He simply wrote them to share with his niece, Lucy. The Holy Observer whote an excellent sarcastic article after the 5th Harry Potter novel offering
new children's books to protest for Christians. The hypocrisy and the picking and choosing of our little "stands" makes us look like fools.

My point is this: I believe this worshipping at the feet of American culture is destructive of the Gospel message. I am not an isolationist. I believe we need to enter the culture and engage and connect with as many people as possible. I also believe we are to be set apart. We can love people without marrying the culture. I am looking forward to the movie, but I will keep it in perspective. I will not sell my soul to Disney.

4 comments:

Jen said...

Disney has been hard on me too. It's tough finding two parents in any of their films. I was afraid of them De-Narniaizing the books, but when I saw the interview with the director and how he read them as a child and how he worked on Shrek... I got o.k. with it. Hopefully he didn't get Disneyfied.

levi fuson said...

dude do you ever post?

Jerry van West said...

I tell you, your point is right on. Our pastor, John Hernandez (Tempe Vineyard - www.tempevineyard.com) seems to echo your thoughts. It's all about a Consumer Christianity. We, as an American society, want everything our way. We want to worship God - but only if it fits our schedule. If church starts at 9:00 and 11:00 am on Sunday morning, we have to stop at Starbucks first to get our coffee fix and when we feel good and ready, we can have the worship team "entertain us" with cool music. We seem to think our sacrifice of praise is "hey, at least we showed up - that's our sacrifice". We try to fit God into our lives versus finding our place in Him.

I love the song "Look What You've Done" from Tree63.

Look what you've done for me
Your blood has set me free
Jesus my Lord
Look what you've done for me

I haven't been the same
Ever since that day I called your name
Yahweh Yahweh look what you've done for me

What can I do for you my Lord?
I want you to know my heart is yours
It's not a question of what you can do for me
But what can I do for you my Lord?

Up to your cross I crawl
Now I am standing ten feet tall
Jesus my saviour look what you've done for me

Free at last I'm free
I owe you my life completely
Yahweh Yahweh look what you've done for me

Do we really feel this way? Do we say, "Free at last I'm free, I owe you my life completely" or is it more like "I owe you my life as it suits me" - I know that I am convicted more each day in trying to shed the cover of consumer Christianity. He is more worthy of our praise and adoraion. Somehow, our culture seems to be missing the boat. The question is - how do we break that cycle and return to true praise and worship.

Desiree said...

Wow. That is a great post that sums up a lot of things. One point that you made in regards to why Narnia and not Potter was unfinished though. The reason(at least that I know of) that Christian were boycotting the Potter series is because of the author. One of the things that she had said in an interview was that she hated christianity and if she had a choice she would cast spells on us or some stupid crap like that. I am paraphrasing of course but, the sentiment is still there.she was pretty vocal about her hatred for christians(Big deal) but I think that was why "we" as Levi puts it"boycotted" the potter books. I still saw the movies...I kinda liked them. I am not going to make a big deal about it one way or another. I watched Resident Evil too. Maybe all my friends should boycott me!
By the way, my name is Desiree Ricker. I am friends with Levi and Beth. My husband and I go to the Vineyard in Valparaiso IN. Man we miss Levi's leading worship. BIG HUGE TIME! Good blog.